This article is a part of Snapshot: Food, a collaborative journalism project between Tulsa Flyer, The Oklahoma Eagle, The Frontier, KOSU, La Semana and Focus Black Oklahoma exploring how Oklahomans put food on the table.
The Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality has added four bodies of water — lakes Bell Cow, Overholser, Fuqua and Ponca — to its growing list of lakes with mercury advisories for fish.
The advisory affects an important food source for many Oklahomans, especially those with lower incomes, people who live in rural or Indigenous communities and those who practice traditional harvesting methods.
Mercury exposure in humans can affect the kidneys and brain and cause learning disabilities in children. Symptoms of exposure to mercury include loss of peripheral vision, “pins and needles” feelings in the hands, feet and around the mouth, lack of coordination of movements, impairment of speech, hearing and walking and muscle weakness.
The Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality, along with the Oklahoma Department of Wildlife, perform routine mercury testing on fish in Oklahoma lakes.

George Russell, who leads the Department of Environmental Quality’s water quality division, said there are a few different ways mercury can contaminate a lake, including natural accumulation, erosion, mining and air emissions from coal-burning power plants.
“It can kind of work its way up the food chain,” Russell said. “Starting with the small little invertebrate animals, and then as the fish eat those, they kind of work their way up.”
This results in shellfish and larger, longer-living predatory fish, often sought after for food by humans, having higher concentrations of mercury.
Thirty-four of the 75 lakes on the state’s mercury advisory list this year were in northeastern Oklahoma. Lead and cadmium left over from the old mines play a major role in the contamination.
Miami sits in what is known as the Tri-State Mining District, which left environmental legacies such as the now abandoned town of Picher, Oklahoma, and the Tar Creek Superfund site.
Rebecca Jim, executive director of LEAD Agency, an environmental organization in Miami, Oklahoma, said widespread mercury in fish advisories are something not likely to go away soon.

The Environmental Protection Agency announced in February that it was rolling back mercury and air pollution standards and monitoring requirements for coal-fired power plants implemented in 2024 under President Joe Biden.
The Trump administration has also prioritized reopening coal-fired plants that had previously been shuttered and upgrading coal-fired generators that were set to be retired. At least three coal-fired units in Oklahoma will get upgrades — two units at OG&E’s Sooner Generating Station in Red Rock and one unit at Grand River Dam Authority’s Grand River Energy Center in Choteau, less than a hundred miles downstream on the Neosho River from Jim.
A few miles west of Choteau is the town of Inola alongside the Verdigris River, which may soon be the site of the country’s largest aluminum smelters, another source of mercury pollution.
The LEAD Agency has helped draw attention to the impacts of the mining waste on the environment and people.
In 2013, the LEAD Agency assisted Harvard School of Public Health and the University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center on a years-long study of 150 fishermen and women in the Miami area, taking hair samples and monitoring for mercury, and recording how many fish they had caught and eaten.
The study did not find evidence of elevated mercury levels in the participants, but discovered evidence that people could lower their exposure levels by eating smaller fish.
“After one three-month period, if they change their behavior in some way — eating smaller fish, smaller portions, fewer portions, they could lower their mercury level,” Jim said. “They could be in charge of themselves.”
“If you like catching big fish, let them go free and have babies. Just don’t eat them,” she said.
One of the more disturbing things the study found, Jim said, was that the highest concentrations of mercury in fish were not in lakes or rivers, but in smaller bodies of water, such as farm ponds.
“The thing that we learned that was the scariest was people that don’t fish in the rivers and don’t fish in the lake,” Jim said. “They stay at home and they fish in their farm pond, and fish in their farm pond is higher in mercury than any of lakes, see, any of the rivers, see, because it is trapped water. That was a surprise. It’s what you would think is safest.”
There are 25 lakes with active mercury advisories in southeastern Oklahoma. Many of those reservoirs have had mercury in fish advisories since 2010, when the list of lakes with advisories consisted of only 16 lakes.

Locally-caught fish species are a staple of many people’s diet in the area, said Matt Gamble, senior manager of wildlife conservation for the Choctaw Nation, which covers most of southeast Oklahoma.
Many people in the area eat fish once or twice a week and keep locally caught catfish or crappie in the freezer.
“For southeastern Oklahoma in general, if you go to any kind of gathering or celebration, a lot of times fish fries are a pretty popular option for that, especially this time of year in the fall, when people are having watch parties for football and different things,” Gamble said.
Ultimately, Gamble said, fish advisories won’t stop mercury from showing up in fish, but it gives people the information they need to eat safely and know what to watch out for.
“It’s kind of a personal preference type situation where, as long as you know what the risks are and you know warning signs and symptoms if you do consume too much, you know what to do,” Gamble said.