Near East 15th Street and South Harvard Avenue, Tulsa’s “Vintage Row” has become a destination for vintage lovers seeking clothing that is both nostalgic and stylish. Each boutique has its own personality, aesthetic and story. This guide spotlights three standout shops: Polly Hester, Tulsa Vintage Co. and Love Me Two Times.
Polly Hester
Located at 1522 S. Harvard Ave., Polly Hester is a curated and boutique-like vintage clothing store with a strong emphasis on 1960s–70s rock star fashion ranging from hippie and punk to disco and rock-and-roll. Although the store’s core focus is in 1960s to 1990s fashion, Polly Hester also carries select pieces from the 1940s through early 2000s, also known as Y2K fashion.
Store owner Sarah Frick said she aims to keep items affordable while still valuing the quality and uniqueness of vintage pieces. Her philosophy is to “move things” so they can have a second life rather than hang on the rack. Be on the lookout for markdowns and the store’s participation in monthly sales such as 10% off clothing during the Vintage Row Sidewalk Sale held every second Saturday of the month.
For those looking for buy-sell-trade opportunities, Polly Hester buys outright by appointment only. Although they do not offer trade or consignment, they might in the future, Frick said. Most of the store inventory is hand-curated from individuals (often older generations looking to downsize) and occasional estate sales. Polly Hester does not source from thrift stores; all items are intentionally selected and curated.
Beyond clothing, Polly Hester offers vinyl records, books and cassettes curated to reflect the shop’s love for music and vintage counterculture. Occasional homewares and small goods are sold via their booth down the road at Love Me Two Times.
Tulsa Vintage Co.
Founded by longtime vintage collector Julee DeLong and co-owner Mike Clark, Tulsa Vintage Co. opened its doors at 1520 S. Harvard Ave. in June 2023. The store offers a curated mix of clothing from all decades, with a strong emphasis on wearable, everyday vintage, ‘90s minimalist staples and denim in a full range of sizes. You’ll also find antique pieces, accessories, hats, turquoise jewelry and playful additions like ‘90s toys and costumes. Additionally, everything on the floor is cleaned, steamed, mended and measured.
Tulsa Vintage Co. also offers buy-sell-trade with walk-ins welcome for small batches and appointments encouraged for larger drops. DeLong said pricing reflects a thoughtful balance: more affordable for everyday pieces, and higher for rare or unique finds. Her goal is to keep a community-conscious pricing philosophy.
To preserve accessibility for community shoppers, store items are never pulled from local thrift stores. Instead, items are sourced through trusted pickers who travel to rural Oklahoma for estate and garage sales. This allows the shop to buy in bulk and keep prices low.
For shoppers who aren’t as confident picking out the perfect vintage piece, the friendly staff at Tulsa Vintage Co. are available to aid customers with personal styling and fittings, particularly for vintage denim.
Love Me Two Times
Love Me Two Times, at 1740 S. Harvard Ave., is a curated vintage collective in Tulsa specializing in clothing from the 1960s through early 2000s.
Founded by former teacher Michael Easter in 2020, the shop hosts around 60 independent vendors, each offering high-quality pieces from bell bottoms and denim jackets to caftans, muumuus and rare leather finds. With a strict 20-year vintage rule and a “killer not filler” philosophy, the store emphasizes well-made, well-cared-for garments that are cleaned, mended and seasonally rotated.
The shopping experience is boutique-style and visually clean — no digging through bins — making it approachable for both casual browsers and serious vintage lovers. Though Love Me Two Times does not offer buy-sell-trade, it’s happy to direct customers to other local vintage shops that do.
A pricing guide ensures shoppers are getting garments that reflect both the time and care invested, while still staying accessible. Prices typically range from $18 to $70, with some rare or high-quality pieces listed higher.
The staff are known for customer service, styling support and willingness to negotiate on high-ticket items. Beyond clothing, shoppers will find vinyl, accessories and costuming options for themed events.
With a name inspired by The Doors’ song “Love Me Two Times,” the store nods to both the music of the past and the concept of giving well-loved items a second (or third, or fourth) life.
Between its deep community ties, commitment to sustainability and strong eye for quality, Love Me Two Times stands out as one of Tulsa’s most beloved destinations for vintage style.
More vintage shops to visit in Tulsa
A-List Tulsa, 1526 S. Harvard Ave.
Harrington Rose Vintage, 2816 E. 15th St.
The Racks Tulsa, 2646 E. 15th St., Suite B
Sara Kate Synar is a freelance contributor to the Tulsa Flyer.
News decisions at the Tulsa Flyer are made independently of our board members and financial supporters. Read more about our editorial independence policy here.